Advertisement
In How Prime Ministers Decide, journalist Neerja Chowdhury analyses the operating styles of the country’s prime ministers through the prism of six decisions of historic significance – the strategy that Gandhi devised to return to power in 1980 post-Emergency, the Shah Bano case, the Mandal Commission, the Babri Masjid incident, Atal Bihari Vajpayee’s nod to nuclear tests, and the Indo-US nuclear deal under Manmohan Singh.
The book claims the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) had made overtures to Gandhi all through the Emergency.
“RSS chief Balasaheb Deoras had written to her several times. Some RSS leaders had reached out to Sanjay Gandhi through Kapil Mohan. Now, in 1977, she would have to see how to respond. But she would have to play this one very carefully,” Chowdhury writes.
Related Articles
Advertisement
Sensing the unhappiness amongst Muslims about the Congress, she wanted to “Hinduise her politics”, aware that a silent nudge from the RSS or even a neutral stand by them towards her might help, Chowdhury says in the book.
According to the author, her book is about power and its exercise by those who held the highest public office. The chapters illustrate how the power of the prime ministers played out under majority rule as well as in a coalition government. The book also claims that in 1980, Atal Bihari Vajpayee was trying to secularise his image while Indira Gandhi was trying to Hinduise the face of the Congress.
“The RSS helped Indira Gandhi come to power in 1980,” Gandhi’s close aide Anil Bali is quoted as saying.
“She knew the RSS had supported her but she never acknowledged it publicly. She used to admit privately that had it not been for the support by the RSS, she could not have won 353 seats, one more than she had won in her heyday in 1971,” Bali claims.
He adds that “increased temple going was not lost” on the RSS leadership.
“RSS chief Balasaheb Deoras had once remarked during the course of a conversation, ‘Indira Gandhi bahut badi Hindu hai (Indira Gandhi is a staunch Hindu).’
“Balasaheb Deoras and his brother saw in Indira Gandhi a potential leader of the Hindus,” Bali is quoted as saying.
The soon to be launched book, published by Aleph Book Company, also says the RSS in 1971 praised Gandhi for hiving off Bangladesh, and weakening Pakistan.
“The then RSS chief Madhav Sadashiv Golwalkar, popularly known as Guruji, wrote to her, ‘The biggest measure of credit for this achievement goes to you.’ In 1974, she won the RSS’s admiration again for exploding the nuclear device – the RSS had always advocated a militarily strong India,” it says.
Chowdhury also writes that what V P Singh did, no one else who had left the Congress over the years had managed to do.
“Neither Chandra Shekhar, nor Sharad Pawar, nor Ramkrishna Hegde, nor Mamata Banerjee, nor Jagan Mohan Reddy. They too had, like VP, severed relations with the Congress leadership in the 1970s, 1980s, and 1990s in the last century, and also in the 21st century.
“Hegde, Pawar, Banerjee, Reddy went on to replace the Congress in their states and became chief ministers, ironically sometimes in alliance with the Congress they had quit. Chandra Shekhar had become prime minister at the head of a rump supported by the larger, domineering Congress.”
But none had managed to create a national alternative to the Congress like Singh did, though it lasted just under a year, she says.
“He brought together almost all the anti-Congress forces, of the Right, Left, Centre, and the regional parties on one platform in the first truly national coalition. It was a three-tiered arrangement, in what was a rare show of Opposition unity. He gave the regional parties a stake in national governance at the centre,” the book says.